This photo captures a modern office space with several blurred figures of business professionals going about their work.

When Clients Follow: Key Takeaways on Non-Solicitation from Three Step Fitness v. Song

When a specialized employee leaves a practice, it is not uncommon for clients to follow them.  But does a client choosing to move equate to unlawful solicitation?  Following up on our earlier Insight on restrictive covenants, a recent BC Supreme Court decision provides clarity on what will or will not constitute solicitation and evidence that the employer will need to establish a breach.

In Three Step Fitness Inc. v Song, 2026 BCSC 2156, Mr. Song, a kinesiologist and Pilates trainer, resigned from a clinic and commenced employment at two other clinics that were direct competitors of Three Step.  When clients asked where he was going, he truthfully disclosed his upcoming moves. One client asked if they could follow him to his new location, to which Mr. Song responded that it was fine by him.

Three Step commenced an action against Mr. Song to enforce restrictive covenants, namely the non-competition and non-solicitation clauses, in its employment contract.  Finding that the non-competition clause was not enforceable, the Court turned to whether Mr. Song had in fact solicited contrary to the non-solicitation clause in his employment agreement.

The Court dismissed the claim, finding no evidence that Mr. Song took any active step to solicit and declined to infer solicitation from the fact that certain clients had stopped attending Three Step.

Solicitation Requires an “Active Step"

Justice Hoffman confirmed that in BC, solicitation requires an active step aimed at inciting someone to switch services, and provided the following examples of conduct that courts have held does not constitute solicitation:

  • Basic Professional Courtesy: Informing clients of the employee’s impending departure when to do otherwise would demonstrate obvious discourtesy.
  • Public Announcements: Placing a newspaper advertisement to announce a new business location without mention of the association with the former employer.
  • Transition Communications: Sending form letters to clients to announce a move to a new firm, including personal phone numbers, and following up with personal calls.

Inference Is Not Evidence

Three Step further argued that it can be inferred that Mr. Song solicited clients who stopped attending Three Step without leading evidence that Mr. Song had actually solicited them.  Declining to make the inference, Justice Hoffman confirmed that the burden rests with the employer to establish not only that clients had left, but that they did so as a result of the former employee’s conduct.

3 Key Takeaways

Not all communications with clients and customers amount to solicitation.     

There must be an active step taken by the employee to solicit clients to leave and the mere fact that clients have left will not be sufficient for the court to infer that solicitation has occurred.   

Employers need to lead evidence that the client left as a result of the conduct of the former employee.