On December 8, 2016, the Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner for
British Columbia (the “OIPC”) issued its first ever Audit and Compliance Report
following an audit of a private sector business. In Audit and Compliance Report P16-
01‒ Over-collected and Overexposed: Surveillance and Privacy Compliance in a
Medical Clinic (the “Report”), the Commissioner determined that a medical clinic’s
use of video and audio surveillance was unauthorized and excessive. Concurrent
with its release of the Report, the OIPC issued guidelines for implementing overt
video surveillance (the “Guidelines”). Taken together, the Report and the Guidelines
indicate that the OIPC takes a restrictive approach to video surveillance.
The audit of the medical clinic (the “Clinic”) was undertaken as a result of a complaint
made by a former employee about the Clinic’s collection of the employee’s personal
information through both video and audio surveillance. The Clinic has eight video
surveillance cameras located throughout the more public areas of the facility,
including the lobby, hallways, back exits and workout room. These cameras collect
the personal images of patients, employees, contractors, and others. Additionally, the
camera in the lobby records audio of those in its proximity, including anyone who
enters the Clinic
The scope of investigation conducted by the OIPC was extensive. The auditors
examined the Clinic’s policies, practices and training programs. They also did an onsite
inspection, an examination of the video and audio surveillance systems, and
interviewed key Clinic staff.
One of the Report’s key findings was that the Clinic was not authorized under British
Columbia’s private sector privacy legislation, the Personal Information Protection Act,
S.B.C. 2003, c. 63 (“PIPA”), to record the personal information of individuals through
either video or audio surveillance because there wasn’t enough evidence of safety or
security issues to satisfy the Commissioner that such recordings would be reasonable or appropriate. Other key findings were that the Clinic was not in compliance with PIPA by both failing to get the consent necessary to collect the personal information of individuals and failing to properly protect and safeguard this personal information once it was collected. The Report also found that the Clinic did not have an effective privacy management program.
The Report made a number of recommendations, including that the Clinic
immediately cease the collection of personal information through video and audio
recordings, that the Clinic’s privacy policies and procedures be updated, that privacy
risk assessments be regularly conducted, that staff undergo regular privacy training,
and that proper information storage, disposal, and security safeguards be
implemented and maintained.
The Guidelines were issued concurrently with the Report, and are intended to assist
organizations in adhering to privacy laws and avoiding liability. The OIPC describes
video surveillance as a “highly invasive technology” that should only be used as a last
resort after less privacy invasive alternatives are exhausted. If the use of video
surveillance is reasonable and authorized by the applicable privacy legislation, the
OIPC suggests that organizations consider the following steps before the system is
- Develop a surveillance policy
- Limit the time your surveillance is active
- Avoid unintended subjects
- Use adequate signage to notify the public
- Store any recorded images in a secure location
- Destroy recorded images when they are no longer needed
- Limit access to recorded images to authorized individuals
- Open access to your surveillance policy
- Consider right of access
- Periodically re-evaluate your need for video surveillance
David is a commercial litigator and privacy lawyer with particular experience in complex commercial and private sector privacy law matters. He advises and represents clients in a variety of areas, including contract and tort ...
Nicole practises in all areas of labour and employment law, including advising clients on wrongful dismissal, labour relations, human rights and privacy issues.
Nicole has represented clients in matters involving labour ...
Lawson Lundell's Labour and Employment Blog provides updates on the most recent legal developments impacting the Canadian workplace and offers practical tips for employers. We cover a range of topics, including labour relations, employment law, collective bargaining, human rights, employment standards, employment equity, workers' compensation, business immigration, privacy, occupational health and safety and pensions and employee benefits.